Codethink is working on a project to design a fully open-source (hardware and software) research device for experimenting with shining light into skin and detecting the light that reflects, gets absorbed and passes through. This kind of technology is widely deployed for measuring heart rates.
Existing technology used in smart watches suffers various shortcomings, such as reduced effectiveness on darker skin tones and tattoos.
This project aims to develop a research testbed that can be used to find alternatives that won’t have the same drawbacks. Our testbed enables multiple LEDs of different wavelengths (colours of light) distributed through the visible and infra-red to be used to uncover other interesting metrics that may be detectable, such as:
Blood sugar levels
Carbon Monoxide levels
Pulse oximeters currently use 2 wavelengths of red/infra-red light to determine blood oxygen levels through a process called photoplethysmography (PPG).
Smart watches and fitness trackers use a simpler mechanism to determine pulse rate. This is done by reading the variations in light reflected by the wearer’s blood using a green LED at a fixed wavelength. This allows a cheaper, lower power but lower accuracy mechanism for reading pulse rate: It also doesn't work as well on darker skin or tattoos.
Our device has the red/infra-red LEDs used by medical pulse oximeters, and the green LED used by smart watches. These can be used to reproduce existing results. We also have a range of wavelengths distributed between 470nm and 1650nm (blue to short-wave infra-red).
At this early stage, we have used a first prototype board and seen a pulse in the data from reflection with the green LED.
The work has been released in the open. It provides a base for others to be able to take the work and be able to apply it in different settings or develop it further. In its current state, it is possible to capture data in various wavelengths, enabling various kinds of data science experimentation.
First prototype design
The device has 16 LEDs and 4 photodiodes. Each of the LEDs emits a different wavelength of light. The four photodiodes have different curves for their sensitivities to different wavelengths of light.
This means that one photodiode might be best at picking up a given LED, and the others might detect it a bit or not at all.
As you can see in the image, our initial revision uses a shaped PCB as a shield to protect the photodiodes from direct illumination, to ensure the light has to pass through the skin before being recorded on the photodiode. When the design is more concrete we’ll likely move towards a professionally 3D printed case.
Some wavelengths pass more easily than others through flesh. The red and infra-red wavelengths used by medical pulse oximeters pass through flesh quite well, while the green wavelength used by smart watch sensors get scattered more and don't penetrate so far.
Our initial prototypes use only the lower wavelengths of light as the components are cheaper and more available, but also because we don’t have sensitivities well tweaked for light transmission through a finger or thumb. We hope to improve this in future revisions of the board based on the information we’ve gathered from our initial prototype.
A medical pulse oximeter emits light on one side of the finger and has a detector located on the other side of the finger. Smart watches have the light source and detector on the same side of the wrist, and they detect what light penetrated a short way into the flesh, scattered and reflected back out.
To handle both of these modes of light propagation, the device is designed so it might be used either standalone (reflection mode), or in tandem with a second device, with one controlling the other via Serial Peripheral Interface (SPI).
The hardware was designed with automated assembly in-mind which limited component choice, however, photodiode amplification is used in many industries which means appropriate components are cheap and widely available.
We designed the initial revision of the hardware as a 4-layer board to allow for improved grounding and shielding which is required for low noise operation of the ADCs. Dedicated ground planes were used for analog, digital and clocking of the board.
The board was designed using a recent build of KiCAD 5 which is well suited to this level of complexity/detail.
The initial design had to make a lot of assumptions about the brightness of the LEDs and the sensitivity of the photodiodes used, because of this we designed it to provide heavy and configurable amplification such that we have a wide margin of error. In future designs, we'll tweak the variables based on our measurements so that less configuration is required and so that we get much more accurate readings.
Firmware and tooling
For the firmware, we chose to use libopencm3 to get something up and running quickly. It provides support for STM32 F3 based microcontrollers. It also makes it easy to build a USB Communications Device Class (CDC) device.
In order to meet our requirements we had to make a few patches to libopencm3:
- stm32f3: Enable GPIO ports G and H (Merged.)
- stm32f3: Add support for OPAMP (Open at the time of writing.)
The firmware reads samples from the photodiodes using the analog-to-digital converters (ADCs).
Acquisition is driven by a timer, which triggers the ADC, which triggers Direct memory access (DMA), which causes an interrupt. In the interrupt handlers for each ADC, a per-ADC sample data message is filled up. When the message buffer is filled, the message is marked as ready, and it is sent over USB to the host inside a poll loop.
On the host side there is a simple tool to generate, send, receive, and decode messages. There is another tool which can convert the decoded messages into WAV files, for easy inspection and processing in Audacity.
We’ve got a Pulse!
The hardware was designed to be as sensitive as possible because we had no way of knowing the real sensitivities of the components selected, nor did we know the strength of the light that would be reflected for any given wavelength.
To get our first pulse we amplified the signal by a gain of 16x as this put the signal from our photodiode within the range of the ADC, we then oversampled the signal by 16 times to generate a 16-bit result. Oversampling in this case works because we know that the noise is random by spectral analysis of the voltage lines.
We decided that the easiest way to view a wave was to treat it as audio as we were likely to use the same frequencies and because audio tools such as Audacity contain basic tools for filtering the output. We created a WAV file exporter to export our sample data as a PCM WAV file which we opened in Audacity.
The initial view of the waveform (shown above) looked interesting as there was low and high-frequency noise. Immediately visible was 50Hz AC noise, but spectral analysis showed some other minor frequency spikes. Since we knew that a pulse rate should be expected to be between 0.5-2 Hz we simply filtered out the high-frequency noise (> 10Hz) which gives the relatively clear image of a pulse shown on the right.
Refining the Data
Our initial pulse signal was a success but the amplitude of a pulse reading was 65 out of 65535, so we were covering only 0.1% of the range. Our hardware is limited to 12-bit resolution (oversampled to 16-bit) and any hardware amplification could easily amplify the signal beyond our measurable range, the only option would be to oversample further.
The first step was to measure the signal from a photodiode under relatively constant illumination, we couldn't use electrical light due to 50Hz (in the UK) AC noise, so we placed the device such that it was reading reflected sunlight and took some samples. On analysis the readings showed that the noise we read on the photodiode was random, there were no frequences visible in an FFT, this was good news since it meant that we could oversample abitrarily and gain accuracy.
We created a mechanism in our firmware to sum samples into a 32-bit integer, we provide an offset and shift which is applied to force the samples into a 16-bit word prior to transmission to save bandwidth. With this and a calibration mechanism to discover the best offset/shift values for a given oversample, we started to see some really interesting results.
In this image we can see that the pulse is now much clearer than before, with it's height occupying a large amount of the total range. The pulse is so clear here we can start to see the systolic and diastolic peaks, but we still have an issue with low frequency noise that can offset the signal quite heavily. These offsets are due to muscle movements, current smart-watches face the same issue since they use the same wavelength of green light as we used here (528nm).
In this image we can see that the pulse level is much more constant, and is effected much less by movement, since infra-red also passes much more easily through dark or tattoo'd skin, it's easy to see why smartwatch vendors believe that red/infra-red light is the future.
As with any project, there is always more that can be done. In this section are a few ideas for interesting directions that this project might be taken.
The main things that would be useful are:
- Support for communicating with a second device over SPI to the firmware. This would enable detection of light that passes through flesh, rather than reflected light.
- Support for the device in libsigrok enabling us to view data in real-time with PulseView.
We see a lot of potential with the improvements for hardware. By optimising components, applying voltage offsets and with the software improvements, we expect we will see 250-1000 times the accuracy. This will also be made easier with an upgraded microcontroller. Further improvements are possible by utilizing higher grade components, however the cost also goes up.
There is also scope to reduce the size of the device, that way it can be more widely used, for instance, to fit on a finger.
The next steps for getting useful readings from the device will focus on getting heart rate data that's clear and reliable. Improvements to the hardware should help with this.
After that, we will be able to examine the data from LEDs of other wavelengths and see if we can correlate the data with what we observe in the green part of the spectrum. There is potential to find wavelengths that can be used to measure heart rates that work on more skin tones or different skin tones. Longer-term, the presence of other important information that can be found in the data, such as hydration, blood sugar levels, and carbon monoxide levels can be investigated.
We're open to collaboration with research institutions and industry; particularly around controlled experimentation targeting specific wavelengths/applications.
This work is fully open-source hardware and software. If you're interested in collaborating, we are happy to take merge requests.
You can find our work so far below:
This contains the KiCad files and other related documentation.
This repository contains the firmware and some simple tools to communicate with the device and acquire sample data.
We welcome anyone to join in, experiment with the work and help us to realise its potential.
- RISC-V: A Small Hardware Project
- Why aligning with open source mainline is the way to go
- Build Meetup 2021: The BuildTeam Community Event
- A new approach to software safety
- Does the "Hypocrite Commits" incident prove that Linux is unsafe?
- ABI Stability in freedesktop-sdk
- Why your organisation needs to embrace working in the open-source ecosystem
- RISC-V User space access Oops
- Tracking Players at the Edge: An Overview
- What is Remote Asset API?
- Running a devroom: FOSDEM 2021 Safety and Open Source
- Meet the codethings: Understanding BuildGrid and BuildBox with Beth White
- Streamlining Terraform configuration with Jsonnet
- Bloodlight: Designing a Heart Rate Sensor with STM32, LEDs and Photodiode
- Making the tech industry more inclusive for women
- Bloodlight Case Design: Lessons Learned
- Safety is a system property, not a software property
- RISC-V: Codethink's first research about the open instruction set
- Meet the Codethings: Safety-critical systems and the benefits of STPA with Shaun Mooney
- Why Project Managers are essential in an effective software consultancy
- FOSDEM 2021: Devroom for Safety and Open Source
- Meet the Codethings: Ben Dooks talks about Linux kernel and RISC-V
- Here we go 2021: 4 open source events for software engineers and project leaders
- Xmas Greetings from Codethink
- Call for Papers: FOSDEM 2021 Dev Room Safety and Open Source Software
- Building the abseil-hello Bazel project for a different architecture using a dynamically generated toolchain
- Advent of Code: programming puzzle challenges
- Improving performance on Interrogizer with the stm32
- Introducing Interrogizer: providing affordable troubleshooting
- Improving software security through input validation
- More time on top: My latest work improving Topplot
- Cycling around the world
- Orchestrating applications by (ab)using Ansible's Network XML Parser
- My experience of the MIT STAMP workshop 2020
- Red Hat announces new Flatpak Runtime for RHEL
- How to keep your staff healthy in lockdown
- Bringing Lorry into the 2020s
- How to use Tracecompass to analyse kernel traces from LTTng
- Fixing Rust's test suite on RISC-V
- The challenges behind electric vehicle infrastructure
- Investigating kernel user-space access
- Consuming BuildStream projects in Bazel: the bazelize plugin
- Improving RISC-V Linux support in Rust
- Creating a Build toolkit using the Remote Execution API
- Trusting software in a pandemic
- The Case For Open Source Software In The Medical Industry
- My experiences moving to remote working
- Impact of COVID-19 on the Medical Devices Industry
- COVID-19 (Coronavirus) and Codethink
- Codethink develops Open Source drivers for Microsoft Azure Sphere MediaTek MT3620
- Codethink partners with Wirepas
- Testing Bazel's Remote Execution API
- Passing the age of retirement: our work with Fortran and its compilers
- Sharing technical knowledge at Codethink
- Using the REAPI for Distributed Builds
- An Introduction to Remote Execution and Distributed Builds
- Gluing hardware and software: Board Support Packages (BSPs)
- Engineering's jack of all trades: an intro to FPGAs
- Bust out your pendrives: Debian 10 is out!
- Why you should attend local open source meet-ups
- Acceptance, strife, and progress in the LGBTIQ+ and open source communities
- Codethink helps York Instruments to deliver world-beating medical brain-scanner
- Codethink open sources part of staff onboarding - 'How To Git Going In FOSS'
- Getting into open source
- How to put GitOps to work for your software delivery
- Open Source Safety Requirements Analysis for Autonomous Vehicles based on STPA
- Codethink engineers develop custom debug solution for customer project
- Codethink contributes to CIP Super Long Term Kernel maintenance
- Codethink creates custom USB 3 switch to support customer's CI/CD pipeline requirements
- Codethink unlocks data analysis potential for British Cycling
- MIT Doctor delivers Manchester masterclass on innovative safety methodology
- Balance for Better: Women in Technology Codethink Interviews
- Introducing BuildGrid
- Configuring Linux to stabilise latency
- Full archive